Skip to content

Cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

Dana Zilberstein: Brand Preservation Is the Commercial Argument, Not the Sentimental One

Oct 31, 20265 min read

When a brand owner asks me whether protecting prestige on the way into a new market is worth the slower start, the question underneath it is usually the same one: is this a matter of taste, or is it a matter of money. I understand why it gets asked that way. Preservation sounds like the soft option, the one you choose when you cannot get the volume. It is not. It is the commercial position, and it is the one I hold at Fine Rituals for every brand we bring into Israel.

I am Dana Zilberstein, Co-Founder and CEO of Fine Rituals, a boutique importer based in Netanya. We bring the world's most exclusive luxury beauty and wellness brands into Israel and we own the entire entry, from regulatory approval through to retail placement. More than twenty international brands have come into this market through us. That number is the reason I can speak plainly about what works here and what does not.

The two options that existed before

Until recently, a prestige brand looking at Israel had two choices, and both of them cost something.

The first was to stay out. Israel looks small on a spreadsheet. For a VP of export with a CFO to answer to, a market of this size rarely justifies a branch, a dedicated team, or a separate vendor relationship. So the file gets closed and the market stays empty.

The second was to enter through a volume distributor. That route moves product. It also tends to flatten a brand into another SKU on a shelf, sold next to things it has nothing in common with, priced and promoted on the logic of turnover. For a founder whose brand is their life's work, that is not a win with a caveat attached. It is a loss.

Sitting behind both options was the regulatory maze. Ministry of Health registration, toxicological review, customs. That alone was enough to keep most brands at the border, regardless of how they felt about placement.

What volume actually costs

Here is why I treat preservation as the commercial argument rather than the emotional one. A luxury brand's price is not a number attached to the ingredients. It is held up by where the product sits, who sells it, who is seen carrying it, and how hard it is to find. Take those supports away and the price has nothing holding it up. Fast turnover and mass shelf space pull every one of them out at once.

Once that happens, the damage is not confined to one market. Pricing and positioning travel. A brand that has been discounted into high turnover in one country has a harder conversation in the next one. So the question is not whether volume brings revenue in the first year. It is what the brand is worth in year three, and whether the founder still recognises it.

That is why our rule is short and why I do not negotiate it: protect the brand first, chase volume never.

Preservation is an operation, not a promise

Any importer can say they respect a brand. What matters is whether the structure behind the words makes it possible. Ours keeps everything under one roof, which means there is no point in the entry where a brand is handed to someone who was not part of the original agreement.

  • Regulatory and registration. Israeli Ministry of Health approval and toxicological review are handled in house. We own the science rather than outsourcing the forms to a third party and hoping the file comes back clean.
  • End to end logistics. International shipping, customs, warehousing and the local supply chain are managed by us, not split across vendors who each know one leg of the journey.
  • Premium positioning. Placement is curated and scarcity led, in boutiques, premium clinics and luxury spas. We deliberately bypass mass retail.

Three things make that difficult to copy. The first is the decision to put brand preservation ahead of volume and to live with it when a large order has to be refused. The second is in-house regulatory and toxicological mastery, which is the part most brands assume has to be farmed out. The third is cultural and aesthetic alignment, which is the one nobody can write into a corporate handbook. Taste is either present in the room where placement is decided or it is not.

My Co-Founder, Ofri Shaysh, builds the market access side of the business and opens the routes premium brands need across Israel, Asia and the Middle East. He works to the same principle, because a brand that is protected through registration and then let go between port and shelf has not been protected at all.

The answer to the small market question

Israel is not a volume market and I do not sell it as one. What it offers a prestige brand is a discerning audience and a set of rooms where being present means something. Entering through a route that keeps exclusivity intact gives a brand a clean record in the region, and that record is what the next market reads.

Where we are going is a gateway for the region. Israel first, then Asia and the Middle East, with the same entry and the prestige intact at larger scale. A brand that enters Israel correctly is already positioned for that. A brand that enters it cheaply has made the next step harder.

If you are weighing the decision

Whether you are a founder with one brand that carries your name or an export lead who needs a launch that holds up in front of a board, the entry route is the same and so is the standard. We handle the regulatory file, the shipping and the customs, and we choose the shelves. You keep the brand you built.

You can read more about my work on the Dana Zilberstein founder page, and more about Fine Rituals at fine-rituals.com. If you want to talk about what entry would look like for your brand, I am the person you will deal with.

Share